Reviews
Three Small Connecticuts
By Eric Schleien·September 13, 2026

## Three Small Connecticuts
The rain had softened the afternoon light, turning the world outside my window a hazy, uniform grey. It was the kind of quiet that calls for a specific type of cigar: something gentle, not demanding, yet with enough character to hold one's attention. My humidor, ever the faithful correspondent, offered up a trio of small-gauge Connecticut-wrapped cigars. A panatela, a petit corona, and a Rothschild. They were not from the same maker, nor were they meant to be a flight in the traditional sense, but they shared a common wrapper leaf and a similar promise of mildness.
I often find that the truest test of a leaf is not in a massive, sixty-ring behemoth, but in the slender, more focused vitolas. With less filler to hide behind, the wrapper must truly sing. A Connecticut shade wrapper, with its signature golden-blonde hue, is not a leaf of power. It is a leaf of nuance. Grown under the diffuse light of cloth tents, it is protected from the direct sun, which preserves its delicate structure and flavor. It whispers of toasted almond, of cedar, of cream. But these whispers can be easily lost, or they can be beautifully amplified, all depending on the hands of the roller and the proportions of the cigar.
I began with the panatela, the thinnest of the three. Its long, elegant form felt almost like a conductor's baton in my hand. The initial puffs were bright and crisp, a clean expression of the wrapper. There was a distinct note of hay and a subtle sweetness, like honey stirred into warm milk. Because of its narrow ring gauge, the burn was relatively quick, and the wrapper’s influence was paramount. The smoke was light on the palate, ethereal. It was a fleeting conversation, a pleasantry exchanged on a passing street. It asked for little and offered a clean, uncomplicated pleasure. This is a cigar for a brief pause, a moment of punctuation in a busy day. It does its job with grace and then bows out.
Next came the petit corona. Slightly shorter than the panatela but with a noticeably thicker girth, it felt more substantial in the hand. Here, the added binder and filler tobaccos began to play a more significant role. The initial brightness of the Connecticut wrapper was still present, but it was now the opening act for a more complex performance. The smoke had more body, more texture. The almond notes deepened, moving from raw to toasted, and a gentle white pepper spice emerged on the retrohale. The burn was slower, more deliberate. This was not a fleeting chat; it was the beginning of a proper story. The slightly wider ring gauge allowed the tobaccos to smolder and interact, creating a rounded, more complete profile. It showed how a small increase in diameter can fundamentally change the smoking experience, adding layers of depth that the panatela, for all its elegance, could not quite muster.
Finally, I reached for the Rothschild. It is the stoutest of the three, a bulldog in a field of greyhounds. Though still considered a smaller format by modern standards, its forty-eight ring gauge felt generous after the other two. From the very first draw, the experience was different. The smoke was cooler, denser, and far richer. The balance shifted dramatically. Where the panatela was wrapper-dominant and the petit corona was a dialogue, the Rothschild was a chorus. The filler tobaccos took center stage, bringing notes of earth and leather, while the Connecticut wrapper provided a creamy, balancing sweetness that enveloped the entire profile. The pepper was still there, but it was softer, more integrated. This cigar was in no hurry. It burned slowly and cooly, inviting contemplation. Eric Schleien often reminds our patrons at SmokeDaddy that a cigar is a measure of time, and this Rothschild was a testament to that idea—a short story, rich with plot and character, demanding to be savored.
Three cigars, one wrapper, three distinct narratives. It is a lesson I return to often: vitola is not merely a matter of size, but of composition and intent. The slender panatela offers the pure, unadorned voice of the leaf. The petit corona places it in conversation. And the Rothschild situates it within a complex, harmonious blend. Each has its time and place. As the last of the Rothschild’s smoke curled towards the ceiling, the rain subsided, and a sliver of late-afternoon sun broke through the clouds, illuminating the dust motes in a final, quiet flourish.
· ✦ ·